Vintage mysteries – Dead dogs and missing wives

Review – The Case of the Howling Dog
by Erle Stanley Gardner

A keeper? Well, probably.

There are a few authors who give me an irrational itch to own every book they published, or at least every book in their main series. Erle Stanley Gardner is one of them, even though in some ways he’s a terrible writer. His writing style improved a bit over the years – but the Howling Dog is one of his earliest Perry Mason books, and it seemed as if every third page told us about Mason confronting somebody or other with his feet wide apart, his shoulders squared, and his head thrust forward. We get it. Mason’s a stand-up guy. He doesn’t let anyone push him, or his clients, around. Now please let him relax before he tips over.

The Howling Dog isn’t exactly a terrible book, though. Gardner had his strong points, and his greatest skill was coming up with complicated plots. This one’s a doozy.

Let’s see. First, Arthur Cartright hires Perry Mason to make his neighbor Clinton Foley stop provoking Foley’s dog to howl. Also, Cartright wants to make a will leaving everything to the woman who is living with Foley as his wife – whether she’s legally Foley’s wife or not.

Next, Foley (not his real name, by the way) convinces the powers that be that his dog never howled in its life, and that Cartright’s dangerously crazy. Cartright mails Mason his will – but now he’s leaving everything to Foley’s legal wife, who may be an entirely different person. (And it turns out that she is.)

Whoever that woman who’s been claiming to be Mrs. Foley is, she seems to have run away – Foley’s housekeeper says she saw her go. And Cartright disappears too.

Maybe he has good reason. Only a few hours later, both Foley and his dog are found shot to death. It looks as if the dog died protecting Foley. Who did it? Cartright? Maybe. Or was it the unknown woman who showed up at Foley’s house by taxi; stayed a little while; and left again, somewhere around the time of the murder? And what about Foley’s housekeeper, a pretty young woman who’s going out of her way to look ugly? She has a good alibi for every minute of the evening – maybe too good.

By the end of the book, we have a pretty clear idea of what happened and who killed Foley (and the dog). The odd thing about this story, though, is that Gardner really seems to be more interested in showing us how Mason uses legal strategy and bluff to win his case than in explaining the mystery. After all, as Mason explains repeatedly to various people, it’s not a defense attorney’s job to prove exactly what happened – it’s his job to protect his client’s interests. And Mason’s very good at doing that.

6 responses to “Vintage mysteries – Dead dogs and missing wives

  1. more good stuff 🙂

  2. I haven’t read an Erle Stanley Gardner for ages! And his secretary, Della Street. I don’t know why I even remember that – it’s got to be 40 years … oh, I shouldn’t say that … remember the tv series too …

    • I won’t tell if you won’t! 😉 One of the things that interests me in these old mysteries is noticing how social customs have changed…it’s amazing to realize that this particular story is almost eighty years old (copyright 1934).

  3. I love the Perry Mason books more than the TV show, which I adore. This Perry Mason is grittier, which makes him sexier. I haven’t read this one yet so I need to get a hold of it.

    • Good point that book-Perry is grittier than TV-Perry. Especially in the books from the first twenty years of the series, you can see why Paul Drake spends so much time fretting that they’re going over the line legally. (Come to think of it, that takes us about to the time that the TV show started. I wonder how much of the contrast was because, especially back then, television was more timid than books, and how much was a cultural shift in the mid-fifties? Maybe from, oh, 1955 to 1965 or thereabouts, people demanded more prim and proper heroes?)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s